1) and VLP ELISA (Fig. 2) data. The target antigens (L1L2 pseudovirus or L1 VLP) were clustered horizontally while the sera were clustered vertically against a heat map representing the Log10-transformed antibody titer data. This approach allowed us to sort the pseudovirus neutralization and VLP ELISA data into clusters of sera displaying similar antigenic profiles. The magnitude and breadth of
the individual serum neutralizing antibody responses against vaccine and non-vaccine types Dolutegravir in vivo permitted intuitive clustering (Fig. 1). Serum samples in Cluster I displayed the highest HPV16 neutralization titers and the broadest coverage of non-vaccine types, while Cluster VI included samples that had intermediate HPV16 neutralization titers and whose
breadth of reactivity extended to HPV31 and HPV33 (Table 1). These data support a generally quantitative relationship between the level of antibodies in vaccinee sera against HPV16 and an ability to recognize non-vaccine types. However, there also appeared to be a number of antibody specificities displayed. Samples within Clusters II, V and VI for example exhibited differential neutralization of HPV33, HPV35 or HPV52, in addition to HPV31 despite similar HPV16 antibody titers. The serological dendrogram based upon VLP ELISA binding titers (Fig. 2) permitted the formation of branches but the ordering of individual sera bore little relation to the arrangement SCH772984 price in the serological dendrogram based upon the pseudovirus neutralization data. The hierarchical clustering of antibody responses also permitted the ranking of the target antigens. Pseudoviruses HPV31 and HPV33 were the nearest antigenic relatives to HPV16 followed by HPV58 (Fig. 1). HPV52 and HPV35 pseudoviruses
clustered together suggesting a close antigenic relationship between these types. The antigenic dendrogram based upon out VLP ELISA data (Fig. 2) was broadly similar such that the nearest antigenic relative to HPV16 was HPV31, followed by two separate clusters of HPV33 and HPV58, and HPV35 and HPV52. These inter-type antigenic relationships had good bootstrap support and differed somewhat from the inter-type genetic distances based upon L1 amino sequence (Fig. 3). Potential differences in cross-neutralizing antibody specificity were addressed by adsorption on, and elution from, individual non-vaccine type VLP. We reasoned that if cross-neutralization was due to antibodies that constitute a minor fraction of the total vaccine antibody repertoire, such an approach should enrich for these specificities in preference to type-specific HPV16 antibodies. Six serum samples (A–F) were selected from Cluster I (Fig. 1) for enrichment and the neutralization titers against pseudoviruses HPV16, HPV31 and another relevant type were determined prior to and post enrichment. Antibodies enriched on non-vaccine type VLP displayed a range of different cross-neutralizing specificities (Fig. 4).
No related posts.